April 16, 2014

FINRA Alleges Annuity Scheme by Two Former MetLife Brokers

business man holding his head with text asking questions about stock broker misconduct

The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) filed a regulatory complaint against two former brokers from MetLife Securities Inc, (a unit of MetLife Inc). The brokers, Christopher Birli and Patrick Chapin, who both worked for MetLife in Williamsville, New York, until 2012, allegedly engaged in a seven-year scheme to inflate their commissions by having customers switch $21 million in annuities. FINRA alleged in their March 27th. complaint that Birli and Chapin allegedly focused primarily on advising employees of the State University of New York who participated in its retirement plan. According to FIRNA, their scheme generated hundreds of thousands of dollars in commissions. This alleged scheme subjected investors to unnecessary risks.

FINRA alleges that the two MetLife brokers, between 2004 and 2007, recommended 45 of customers switch MetLife variable annuities which were held in their retirement accounts to new variable annuities held in individual retirement accounts (IRAs) outside the university plan.

According to FINRA's complaint, Birli and Chapin structured the deals in a way to circumvent a MetLife policy that generally prohibited exchanging the two types of variable annuities in the transactions. The brokers advised clients to first cash in their retirement plan annuities and buy another security within the plan to hold for 90 days. Clients would then sell that security to buy a variable annuity through an IRA. The new annuity could tie up the investors' funds for as much as seven years and also some clients had to pay fees to cash in their initial annuities.

According to FINRA's BrokerCheck,
Christopher Birli was previously registered with the following FINRA firm(s):

METLIFE SECURITIES INC. (CRD# 14251) - WILLIAMSVILLE, NY
03/2001 - 04/2012

METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY (CRD# 4095) - WILLIAMSVILLE, NY
03/2001 - 07/2007

Patrick Chapin was previously registered with the following FINRA firm(s):

METLIFE SECURITIES INC. (CRD# 14251) - WILLIAMSVILLE, NY
01/2001 - 04/2012

METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY (CRD# 4095) - WILLIAMSVILLE, NY
01/2001 - 07/2007

NATHAN & LEWIS SECURITIES, INC. (CRD# 8503) - NEW YORK, NY
05/1993 - 02/2001

AETNA INVESTMENT SERVICES, LLC (CRD# 34815) - WINDSOR, CT
10/1993 - 01/2001

AETNA LIFE INSURANCE AND ANNUITY COMPANY (CRD# 13256) - HARTFORD, CT
08/1993 - 10/1993

COPELAND EQUITIES, INC. (CRD# 7447) - SOMERSET, NJ
09/1991 - 11/1992

GUARDIAN INVESTOR SERVICES CORPORATION (CRD# 6635) - NEW YORK, NY
05/1991 - 09/1991

This ends FINRA's information.

If you or a loved one have experienced investment losses due to your stock broker/financial advisor’s recommendations of annuities, call Soreide Law Group for a free consultation with an attorney on how to potentially recover your losses: 888-760-6552.

S H A R E   T H I S   P O S T

Recent Posts

November 20, 2026
Wesley Palmer Named In Pending BDC And Interval Fund Arbitration

Madison Avenue Securities shows up on BrokerCheck beside a pending customer arbitration naming Wesley Palmer (CRD 6433982). The product at issue is a BDC or interval fund. The allegations are unproven, and no party has paid anything on the claim.

November 20, 2026
Matt Ward: FINRA Discretion Findings And A $137,500 Settlement

FINRA entered findings against Matt Ward (CRD 2075525) over his trading authority in customer accounts. He consented without admitting or denying them. BrokerCheck also lists settled customer disputes at Alliance Global Partners and Euro Pacific Capital.

November 17, 2026
Deborah Key: Pending $1.5 Million Annuity And Life Insurance Claim

A variable annuity and life insurance are the products in a pending claim against Deborah Key (CRD 1236421). Its allegations are unproven, and no money has been paid on it.

Contact us Nationwide USA
2401 E. Atlantic Blvd., Suite 305, Pompano Beach, FL 33062
Helping clients recover money across the USA
search
Copyright © 2026 Soreide Law Group, PLLC  |  All Rights Reserved