April 3, 2012

Financial Advisers Put Profits in Front of Their Clients, Finds Undercover Study

business man holding his head with text asking questions about stock broker misconduct

In an April 2nd., 2012, article on ThinkProgress.com, Travis Waldon writes that former Goldman Sachs trader Greg Smith publicly resigned three weeks ago, decrying the firm’s “toxic and destructive" culture in a scathing New York Times editorial. But it isn’t just traders at America’s biggest investment bank that view their clients as “muppets,” at least according to a new study from the National Bureau of Economic Research.

In 2008, the authors conducted an undercover study in which trained actors made more than 300 visits to financial advisers available to the general public through banks, brokerages, and investment advisory firms. The results: “Financial advisers not only fail to curb investors’ worst habits, they actually tend to reinforce them — especially when those habits generate fees for the advisers,” as SmartMoney reports:

So, when the actors came into these offices, what happened? Basically, the advisers advised the dummy clients to do a whole lot of things that were in the advisers’ interests, while making some adjustments based on just how much they thought the clients could be persuaded to do.

Most strikingly, the advisers nudged people in low-cost index funds toward high-fee actively managed funds — blatantly making their clients worse off.

Even worse, those without knowledge of financial advising and their own portfolios aren’t aware of how bad the service can be. Despite the study’s findings, the actors were willing to return to 70 percent of the advisers.

Waldon writes that the researchers used an array of portfolios with differing strategies and degrees of risk in the study, but found that financial advisers recommended a change in strategy — often toward “active management” that increased their fees or commissions — 85 percent of the time. And when advisers did mention fees, they “downplayed them without lying,” the authors of the study found.

Securities Lawyer, Lars K. Soreide, of Soreide Law Group, PLLC, has represented clients nationwide. If you or a family member have sustained investment losses due to your stock broker or financial advisor’s recommendations, call for a free consultation on how to potentially recover your losses. To speak with an attorney call 888-760-6552, or visit our website at: www.securitieslawyer.com.

Soreide Law Group, PLLC., representing investors nationwide before FINRA the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority.
S H A R E   T H I S   P O S T

Recent Posts

November 20, 2026
Wesley Palmer Named In Pending BDC And Interval Fund Arbitration

Madison Avenue Securities shows up on BrokerCheck beside a pending customer arbitration naming Wesley Palmer (CRD 6433982). The product at issue is a BDC or interval fund. The allegations are unproven, and no party has paid anything on the claim.

November 20, 2026
Matt Ward: FINRA Discretion Findings And A $137,500 Settlement

FINRA entered findings against Matt Ward (CRD 2075525) over his trading authority in customer accounts. He consented without admitting or denying them. BrokerCheck also lists settled customer disputes at Alliance Global Partners and Euro Pacific Capital.

November 17, 2026
Deborah Key: Pending $1.5 Million Annuity And Life Insurance Claim

A variable annuity and life insurance are the products in a pending claim against Deborah Key (CRD 1236421). Its allegations are unproven, and no money has been paid on it.

Contact us Nationwide USA
2401 E. Atlantic Blvd., Suite 305, Pompano Beach, FL 33062
Helping clients recover money across the USA
search
Copyright © 2026 Soreide Law Group, PLLC  |  All Rights Reserved