The Soreide Law Group has important information to share with you in regard to securities broker Arthur Mel Coffey (“Mel Coffey”) (CRD#: 2553466, Miller Place, New York). Specifically, Coffey, who worked for securities firms Legend Securities, First Standard Financial Company, and SW Financial, is under investigation by FINRA, who oversees most securities brokers in the country. Moreover, 14 investor disputes are reported on BrokerCheck, where investors allege sales practice violations by Coffey. Let’s take a look at these disclosures, including how you might be able to recover your investment losses.
Evidently, FINRA opened a case on Mel Coffey in August 2021. The regulator, who has the power to discipline securities brokers for misconduct, made a preliminary assessment on Coffey and believes that enforcement action is warranted. Supposedly, Coffey could have violated FINRA rules on excessive and unsuitable trading. It is unclear at this time what firm(s) Coffey worked for or whether FINRA will actually bring disciplinary action against him.
Also, a client of John Thomas Financial brought a dispute about Mel Coffey alleging unsuitable private placements. Suitability generally concerns a client’s investment objectives, risk tolerance, and financial needs. Evidently, the securities firm opted to settle this matter by making a $5,000 payment to the client.
Moreover, Mel Coffey and John Thomas Financial are named in a FINRA Arbitration Claim which alleges unsuitability, breach of contract, churning, and failure to supervise. The arbitrator determined that some respondents were liable and required them to pay $16,000. The FINRA Award states that the client settled claims against Coffey.
Notably, a client of John Thomas Financial disputed Mel Coffey’s stock trading. Namely, the client contends that Coffey was excessively trading in the client’s account. Supposedly, the client sustained damages on unsuitable equity transactions. For this reason, John Thomas Financial opted to settle with the client by making a $14,500 payment to the client.
Other investor disputes allege one or more of the following: unauthorized trading, poor performance, churning, misrepresentation, negligence, and breach of fiduciary duty. FINRA BrokerCheck shows that the majority of the investor disputes have settled or resulted in an Award. Some of those disputes concern Coffey’s activities at Gaines Berland Inc., Ladenburg Capital Management, and John Thomas Financial.
Did securities broker Mel Coffey cause you to experience losses? If so, call Soreide Law Group at (888) 760-6552 and speak with a skilled securities lawyer about a potential recovery of your losses. Soreide Law Group represents clients on a contingency fee basis and advances all costs. The firm has recovered meaningful compensation for United States investors who incurred losses from their financial advisors and securities brokers. Please note that Coffey denies all allegations of his sales practice violations.
Summit Brokerage and Independent Financial Group each appear on a pending customer claim naming Gilbert Conrad (CRD 2746778). Both claims are unproven allegations. His BrokerCheck report also lists settled disputes at Arkadios Capital and Independent Financial Group.
On August 6, 2026, a customer filed a $400,000 FINRA arbitration naming Chad McQuade (CRD 5436281) and Northwestern Mutual. The claim involves outside, third-party real estate investments. It is pending, and McQuade disputes it in a written response.
Christopher Miller (CRD 4044818) has a customer dispute on BrokerCheck that settled on October 7, 2026 for $50,901. The disclosure lists Emerson Equity as the firm.
Phone:
Fax: 1-954-760-6553
Email: [email protected]