July 28, 2025

Craig Thistlethwaite Fined, Linked To Morgan Stanley Client’s Negligence Complaint

woman with glasses in front of a line graph smiling at the camera

Investors potentially experienced sales practice violations because of securities broker Craig Sherman Thistlethwaite [CRD: 2507050, Perrysburg, Ohio], according to publicly available information reported on FINRA BrokerCheck. Craig Thistlethwaite worked for Morgan Stanley from June 1, 2009 to February 16, 2023. Read below to learn more about the regulatory action taken against Thistlethwaite.

FINRA Fined Craig Thistlethwaite For Unauthorized Trading

Evidently, on July 24, 2024, FINRA issued Case: 2023077934901 sanctioning Craig Thistlethwaite. FINRA alleged that Thistlethwaite executed unauthorized discretionary trades and used unapproved communication methods with clients.

According to FINRA’s findings, between January 2014 and April 2021, Craig Thistlethwaite placed trades in clients’ accounts without written authorization. This activity violated NASD Rule 2510(b) and FINRA Rules 3260(b) and 2010, which require brokers to obtain written client authorization and firm approval before exercising discretionary transactions.

Additionally, Thistlethwaite communicated with a client about securities using an unapproved channel under Morgan Stanley’s policies. Section 17(a) of the Securities Exchange Act and FINRA Rule 4511 required the preservation of those messages. This led to Morgan Stanley maintaining incomplete books and records, which is also a violation of FINRA Rule 2010.

These violations originated from the circumstances disclosed in Morgan Stanley’s February 16, 2023, Form U5, which indicated concerns regarding Thistlethwaite’s unauthorized trading.

 FINRA accepted Thistlethwaite’s Letter of Acceptance, Waiver, and Consent (AWC), which resolved the case and included the sanctions. Specifically, Thistlethwaite was suspended for 60 days and fined $10,000.

Thistlethwaite also surrendered his Oho investment adviser registration license on December 11, 2024, according to an Ohio Division of Securities Consent Order.

Morgan Stanley Investor Accused Thistlethwaite Of Unsuitable Recommendations

In addition, a Morgan Stanley client filed FINRA Arbitration No. 22-00218 about Craig Thistlethwaite. Allegedly, Thistlethwaite made unsuitable recommendations about a stock options strategy. For this reason, the client allegedly experienced damages. Therefore, on December 29, 2022, Morgan Stanley settled this matter by paying the client $4,200,000.00 in damages.

Craig Thistlethwaite Disclosed Breach Of Fiduciary Duty Allegations By Morgan Stanley Client

Additionally, a client of Morgan Stanley contested Craig Thistlethwaite’s sales practices in FINRA Arbitration No. 21-02127. Mainly, the investor alleged that Thistlethwaite committed unauthorized trading, breached his fiduciary duty, failed to supervise, violated FINRA rules, breached a contract, and was negligent. It appears that Morgan Stanley caused the client to sustain damages connected to options and technology stocks. Consequently, FINRA Arbitrators issued an Award dated December 1, 2022, compelling Morgan Stanley to compensate the client in the amount of $11,500,000.00.

Were You Impacted By Securities Broker Thistlethwaite?

Do you need clarification on any investment losses relating to Craig Thistlethwaite? You should reach out to Soreide Law Group online or at (888) 760-6552 and consult with a securities lawyer regarding a possible recovery. Soreide Law Group is experienced at recovering losses for investors located within the US. Also, the firm works on a contingency fee basis and advances all costs. Thistlethwaite and brokerage firms Thistlethwaite worked for deny allegations of sales practice violations.

S H A R E   T H I S   P O S T

Recent Posts

November 20, 2026
Wesley Palmer Named In Pending BDC And Interval Fund Arbitration

Madison Avenue Securities shows up on BrokerCheck beside a pending customer arbitration naming Wesley Palmer (CRD 6433982). The product at issue is a BDC or interval fund. The allegations are unproven, and no party has paid anything on the claim.

November 20, 2026
Matt Ward: FINRA Discretion Findings And A $137,500 Settlement

FINRA entered findings against Matt Ward (CRD 2075525) over his trading authority in customer accounts. He consented without admitting or denying them. BrokerCheck also lists settled customer disputes at Alliance Global Partners and Euro Pacific Capital.

November 17, 2026
Deborah Key: Pending $1.5 Million Annuity And Life Insurance Claim

A variable annuity and life insurance are the products in a pending claim against Deborah Key (CRD 1236421). Its allegations are unproven, and no money has been paid on it.

Contact us Nationwide USA
2401 E. Atlantic Blvd., Suite 305, Pompano Beach, FL 33062
Helping clients recover money across the USA
search
Copyright © 2026 Soreide Law Group, PLLC  |  All Rights Reserved